‘He could get killed’: Information war inflates Israel-Gaza fight as fake news spreads
- Conspiracy theories accuse both Palestinians and Israelis of being ‘crisis actors’ and faking injuring and deaths for sympathy
- Claims have followed US mass shootings and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and exploded during recent conflict due to less content moderation at platforms such as X
This photo illustration taken in Jerusalem on November 10, 2023 shows a person watching a computer screen (L) displaying content of an amputee spread over social media amid a disinformation campaign downplaying the horrors of the Israel-Gaza war. Photo: AFPMonths after he was discharged from hospital, his right leg amputated, Mohammed Zendiq saw his image swirling online in a vicious disinformation campaign downplaying the horrors of the Israel-Gaza war.
The 16-year-old is one of many civilians on both sides caught in a haze of disinformation since Palestinian militants smashed through the highly militarised border on October 7, triggering an Israeli bombardment and invasion of Gaza.
The information war running in parallel with the deadly conflict on the ground has seen conspiracy theorists accuse ordinary Palestinians and Israelis of being “crisis actors” – feigning injuries and deaths to garner sympathy and demonise the other side.
WHO warns of ‘rapid spread’ of disease in Gaza
An old video that shows Zendiq wounded in a hospital bed was falsely identified in multiple social media posts as depicting a Palestinian blogger who has chronicled the Israeli bombardment of Gaza.
The posts peddled the false narrative that the blogger had staged the injuries one day while walking around seemingly unharmed soon after.
“Palestinian blogger ‘miraculously’ healed in one day from ‘Israeli bombing,’” an Israeli influencer said in one post viewed millions of times on X, formerly Twitter.
“Yesterday, he was ‘hospitalised,’ today, he is … walking like nothing happened.”
But the posts conflated images of separate people, Agence France-Presse fact-checkers determined, using reverse image and keyword searches.
One was Zendiq, who lost his leg in July during an Israeli raid in the occupied West Bank, according to his family. The other was an unrelated video blogger in Gaza named Saleh Aljafarawi.
Highlighting the real-world ramifications of wartime disinformation, the viral posts sparked an avalanche of online abuse targeting Zendiq, including comments asking why doctors did not cut off the teenager’s second leg or kill him.
“I fear for my son’s life,” Zendiq’s father Yousef Issam Fandqah, 50, told Agence France-Presse. “He could get killed because of this lie.”
Your Voice: Innocent suffer in war in Gaza Strip (long letters)
Falsely accusing people of faking their suffering has become “one of the most predictable” disinformation tactics in a crisis scenario, said Mike Caulfield, who researches online falsehoods at the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public.
Similar “crisis actor” claims have followed US mass shootings and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
But such narratives have exploded with the Israel-Gaza war, in part because of a scaling back of content moderation at platforms such as X, experts told Agence France-Presse.
Some of the most viral posts targeting war-afflicted Gazans have used the term “Pallywood”, a derogatory label blending “Palestine” with “Hollywood.”
“This trend initially emerged in the early days of the war, with a video revealing the behind-the-scenes of a film set and alleging it portrayed Palestinians fabricating injuries,” Yotam Frost, from the Israeli disinformation watchdog FakeReporter, told Agence France-Presse.
As the war progressed, Israelis were also caught up in the false narratives, Frost added.
Agence France-Presse fact-checkers have debunked multiple “crisis actor” claims, which often misrepresent visuals from entirely different years and places.
Official Israeli accounts on X, including embassies, falsely charged that a video of a dead Palestinian child in fact showed nothing more than a doll wrapped in cloth.
Other accounts mislabelled footage of a 2013 protest in Egypt and a funeral preparation course in Malaysia as Palestinians acting out their own deaths.
A Thai mother’s Facebook pictures of her young son in a Halloween costume ricocheted across social media alongside false claims that they showed a Palestinian “actor”.
“It’s a set of recipes – Find a couple pictures of people that look similar or sift through behind-the-scenes video of films and find something you can pretend is faking a war,” Caulfield said.
“Crisis actor narratives often take the worst moment of a parent or partner’s life – the loss of a loved one – and make a circus of it. It’s cruel and exploitative.”
Israel’s relentless bombardment and ground invasion of Gaza has killed 11,240 people, according to Gaza’s Hamas-run government.
It followed the Hamas attack on southern Israel – the worst since the country’s founding in 1948 – which Israeli officials say killed about 1,200 people. Hamas militants also took about 240 hostages back to Gaza, the Israeli military estimates.
How to handle the mental health impacts of distressing news
By discrediting the experience of those on the ground, the “crisis actor” allegations are polarising public opinion and risk stoking violence.
“If you believe these deaths are staged, you become more insensible – or sceptical – towards the atrocities of war,” Alessandro Accorsi, a senior analyst at the International Crisis Group of analysts, told Agence France-Presse.
“It is very dehumanising. It is clearly meant to sow doubts about civilian deaths overall and rally support for more violence and attacks.”