bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

knowledgeQuestion

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Mabel Lui

On December 7, 1970, German chancellor Willy Brandt famously fell to his knees after laying a wreath of white flowers at the foot of the Monument to the Ghetto Heroes, in Warsaw, Poland.
This gesture of penance, on behalf of Germany for crimes committed by the Nazis, was one of the first political apologies that was broadcast on television for the public to see.
Today, that video clip constitutes the opening of Apologies, a three-channel video installation by Taiwanese-American artist and filmmaker James T. Hong.
Featuring 161 televised political apologies, the work shows politicians from around the world – including presidents, heads of state and cabinet ministers – offering apologies for their nations’ various crimes against humanity.

The installation, on show at Empty Gallery in Tin Wan, Aberdeen, as part of Hong’s solo exhibition “Apologies and Other Regrets”, was first presented by the artist in 2012.
Back then, the video lasted around an hour; now it runs for seven hours and seven minutes, with the apologies appearing in chronological order: from that of Willy Brandt in 1970 to Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte’s 2022 apology for the Netherlands’ role in slavery.

Hong came up with the idea after encountering many Chinese people who claimed that Japan never apologised for the second Sino-Japanese war. At the time, he was interviewing and conducting research on the victims of political and biological warfare for his documentaries.
“Originally, I would correct them and say that Japan actually did apologise a few times,” he says. “But the Chinese I encountered never believed me, so I started compiling these apologies, starting with Japan, and then it spread to other nations.”
Year after year, the artist updated Apologies with new recordings. Today it provides a snapshot of modern history while accounting for some of the world’s most egregious atrocities.
I doubt there are politicians who just feel bad […] The point of an apology [is] to gain political capital
James T. Hong
The clips include United States president Ronald Reagan’s 1988 apology to the Japanese-Americans who were interned during World War II; Guatemalan president Alfonso Portillo’s 2001 apology for the Dos Erres massacre of more than 200 villagers; Pope Francis’ 2014 apology for Catholic Church sexual abuse; the 2015 apology of Japanese minister of foreign affairs, Fumio Kishida, on behalf of prime minister Shinzo Abe, for the Japanese military’s use of South Korean “comfort women”, forced into prostitution during Japan’s occupation; and French President Emmanuel Macron’s 2021 apology for French mistreatment and abandonment of Algerian Harki fighters.
“I’m a completist,” Hong says of his decision to include every relevant apology he can find. “That’s why it’s over seven hours long.”
For visitors, these seven hours offer much to dissect and consider. First, there is the inherently performative nature of these political apologies – often, they feature a sense of false sincerity, passive language, and narrative arcs that appeal to people’s emotions.
“Most of the apologies, to me, are bulls***,” Hong says. “This is just the truth. Not all, but most, deal with unpardonable crimes against humanity.

“I doubt there are politicians who just feel bad about something and want to apologise for it […] The point of an apology [is] to gain political capital.”
If visitors watch Apologies from start to finish they will see that Western and liberal nations tend to apologise more, given the need for their politicians to sustain widespread public support and thus maintain influence. But other nations have become increasingly willing to apologise as well, Hong explains.
Over time, the apologies have got longer and more polished; the subject matter addressed has also evolved, he says.
“There is a liberal progression of topics that can be addressed and can be apologised for,” he says. “When Germany was first apologising for the Holocaust, just a few decades after World War II, one would never think of apologising to African-Americans, to Native Americans, or to the LGBTQIA+ [community].”
Of interest is not just the countries that choose to apologise but the ones that do not.
Governments are supposed to protect their citizens, but in the end, oppress them
James T. Hong
Certain Eastern European countries that had Communist governments, for example, do not tend to apologise – there is only one clip in Apologies from Russia (it doesn’t feature Vladimir Putin) – and there are certain non-democratic countries in Asia that refrain from televised apologies as well.
“I don’t have any state apology from Vietnam, and there are no apologies from Thailand, which is a monarchy – which is fascinating,” Hong says.
“Thailand is a developing country with human rights abuses every day. You’d think they have a lot to apologise for, but Thailand never has, not that I know of.”
And while the frequency of apologies has accelerated over the years, Hong is generally critical of them because they rarely lead to change. “It’s not the apology that’s so important. It’s the accountability and justice that’s more important.”
Aside from Apologies, Hong is also showing Stabbed in the Back, a series of four sculptures that portray the state of betrayal.
Inspired by the British fable of the Sword in the Stone, the sculptures each feature an artificial styrofoam rock being stabbed by a real bayonet used during the second Sino-Japanese war, which Hong sourced from collectors and Japanese soldiers.
“This relates to Apologies, too – how governments are supposed to protect their citizens, but in the end, oppress them,” he says.

“I thought more about literally being stabbed in the back, so about a best friend gossiping on you, a spouse divorcing you, a family member betraying you, and how this idea of trust and betrayal becomes a universal experience that we all have that doesn’t necessarily result in death, but still can result in psychological trauma.”
“Apologies and Other Regrets”, Empty Gallery, 18-19/F, Grand Marine Centre, 3 Yue Fung Street, Tin Wan, Tue-Sat 11am-7pm. Until August 17.


How US artist Mark Bradford teamed up with Hong Kong students ahead of his new exhibition

More pandas are great, but let’s also grow Hong Kong as a city of art

Christie’s CEO on hopes for new Asia HQ in Hong Kong, and its place in global art market

Can you really distil the taste of whisky in an art installation? Hong Kong Renaissance woman Elaine Ng thinks so

From the Pope to Macron, world leaders’ apologies compiled for artist’s Hong Kong show

Pope Francis apologising for sexual abuse by Catholic Church figures of authority, as shown in James T. Hong’s video compilation of world leaders saying sorry, Apologies, now showing in Hong Kong. Photo: Edmond So

James T. Hong at Empty Gallery in Hong Kong, where he is showing his solo exhibition. Photo: Mabel Lui

Hong’s video piece Apologies runs for seven hours and seven minutes. Photo: Edmond So

Hong doesn’t think much of the apologies his exhibition showcases; he believes they’re mostly hollow rhetoric from politicians seeking to gain political capital. Photo: Edmond So

One of the four sculptures in Hong’s “Stabbed in the Back” series on show at his Hong Kong exhibition. Photo: Mabel Lui

Scents from the past waft through Hong Kong show on Chinese fragrance culture


Detail from Lady Reclining on a Cage over a Censer by Chen Hongshu. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art

A hanging censer from the Qing dynasty is one of more than 150 pieces featured in Fragrance of Time – In Search of Chinese Art of Scent, an exhibition at the Hong Kong Museum of Art. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art

Lady Reclining on a Cage over a Censer by Chen Hongshu is one of two grade-one Chinese national treasures featured in the exhibition. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art 

A gold-painted stone Buddha dating back to the Southern Liang dynasty is the other grade-one national treasure featured at the exhibition. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art

A carved red lacquer incense box in the form of imperial palace from the Qing dynasty featured in the exhibition. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art 

Max Cheng Chi-kin’s A Story of Time Through Scents features nearly 50 herbs and other materials intended to evoke the scents of dawn, noon and dusk. Photo: Hong Kong Museum of Art

‘A weird separation’: life in Taiwan goes on despite invasion fear, documentary maker says

S. Leo Chiang shooting on a Quemoy Islands beach. Photo: Yorke Wu

S. Leo Chiang films at the Beishan Broadcast Wall, a bank of 48 loudspeakers on the Quemoy Islands once used to blast Taiwanese propaganda towards nearby Xiamen in mainland China. Photo: courtesy of Island In Between

Chiang photographs himself in a mirror. Photo: courtesy of Island In Between

Chiang shooting on a Quemoy Islands frontline beach. Photo: Yorke Wu

Anti-landing spikes on a Quemoy Islands beach, with Xiamen in the distance. Photo: courtesy of Island In Between

A rusting, sunken tank on Oucuo Beach, Quemoy Islands. Photo: courtesy of Island In Between

How Japanese nail art is keeping traditional wood lacquer technique alive

A nail artist is working with a traditional wood lacquerware craftsman in central Japan to create distinctive false nails that combine both arts. Photo: Instagram/@sucre_nail_

Naoko Sato runs a nail salon in Takayama, central Japan. Photo: Instagram/@sucre_nail_

Wood lacquerware is being kept alive by being combined with nail art in Takayama, Japan. Photo: Instagram/@sucre_nail_

The lacquerware nails are very distinctive. Photo: Instagram/@sucre_nail_

Magazines

PostMag

Arts & Music

Lifestyle

Arts & Culture

Apologies and Other Regrets by James T. Hong features clips of politicians saying sorry for their nations’ crimes – the artist asks why


Taiwanese-American James T. Hong’s exhibition Apologies and Other Regrets features a video compilation of leaders apologising for their countries’ misdeeds. The artist calls their motives into question.


What to do in Hong Kong

History

Algeria

Guatemala