Advertisement

The View | Immigration is good for business, not a burden, in Hong Kong and the rest of the world

Stephen Vines says Hong Kong need only look to its own history to discover the truth in the reams of research that highlight the benefits of immigration to society

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
People cross the Lok Ma Chau border station from Shenzhen into Hong Kong on September 4. Photo: Roy Issa
Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor may well have political reasons for extolling the contribution of immigrants to Hong Kong society but it makes a change from the routine immigrant bashing that is high on the political agenda elsewhere in the world.
Advertisement
Lam, however, only addressed the issue of immigrants coming to Hong Kong under the daily quota system designed to facilitate family reunions but managed some passing reference to the obvious fact that Hong Kong is an “immigrant society”. Indeed, this city owes much of its dynamism to this self-selecting group of people who upped sticks to escape Communist rule, but there’s an embarrassing political message in that particular narrative.

Anyway, that’s how Hong Kong developed and it remains strange that this place, a poster child for the advantages of immigration, has no coherent immigration policy, aside from the one ensuring that the Hong Kong government has no say in who comes here under the daily quota system, leaving it entirely to the mainland authorities.

Aside from this, the government has shown limited interest in immigration policy outside the technology sector, despite the fact that imported labour makes a major contribution in industries ranging from tourism to health care and food and drink, all of which are big contributors to the economy.
At least Hong Kong politicians have been less inclined to sign up for the anti-immigrant demagoguery that is dominating the political debate in countries such as the United States that were built on immigration. In a number of other places where immigrants have made incredible contributions to society, they are now being demonised.
Advertisement
The range of these countries is breathtaking, from South Africa, where there is a backlash against immigration from elsewhere in Africa, to Sweden and the Netherlands, traditionally regarded as open-minded on this issue, and Germany where the immigration debate threatens to bring down Chancellor Angela Merkel, arguably Europe’s most successful leader.
Advertisement