Advertisement

Asian Angle | Gaza and ‘the graveyard for children’: the moral decline of Western politics

  • Weak Western leaders, certain of their own exceptionalism, have endangered world peace by peddling narratives that justify the unjustifiable
  • Abuse of the charge of antisemitism silences those calling for an end to the bloodshed, fomenting a callous response to the killing of Palestinians

Reading Time:6 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
23
South Korean activists supporting Palestinians in Gaza attend an anti-US protest on Thursday during US Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s visit to Seoul. Photo: Reuters

Irrespective of your political beliefs, the reality is that the worst wars of this century have a common thread: Western intervention, instigation, or historical entanglement.

Advertisement
Today’s two most significant wars – Ukraine and Israel-Gaza – are no different. The West, led by the United States, has not been involved in its self-proclaimed capacity as a global peacemaker. Instead, it has played a role that the majority of the world views as self-serving, instigating, enabling, and deepening these conflicts.

As the horrors of the month-long assault on Gaza’s civilian population stuns and numbs onlookers, people around the world are left wondering why and how Western powers have stood in the way of calls for a ceasefire that would put a stop to the daily vengeful killing and save the lives of innocent people – mainly children.

Palestinians look for survivors in a crater made by an Israeli strike on a refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip on October 31 in this still from video footage. Photo: AFP
Palestinians look for survivors in a crater made by an Israeli strike on a refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip on October 31 in this still from video footage. Photo: AFP
United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres has warned that the Gaza Strip is fast becoming “a graveyard for children”. He, too, has called for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire. For his remarks, he was attacked by Israel and told to resign. More Palestinian children have been killed in Gaza over the last month – close to 4,500 at the last estimate - than the total number killed in the West Bank and Gaza combined between 1967 and this year.

The blocking of a ceasefire option by Western powers has brought to the fore a recurrent question: what are the reasons for the moral bankruptcy within Western societies, and especially their political leaders? This is being asked across the world, including by some of the West’s leading public intellectuals.

European and American friends of mine working at various institutions have posed the same question in social-media chat groups, but feel unable to publicly voice their concerns at home. Despite all the grandstanding about freedom of speech in the West, there is a clear obstacle presenting itself here: the fear of being accused of being an antisemite runs deep, even if one is simply asking for the bloodshed to stop.

Levelling the charge of antisemitism against anyone who questions Israel’s crimes against Palestinians is an abuse that needs to be challenged so that it does not become normalised across the world. This practice has silenced many in the West and allowed its politicians to lose their moral compass. It is not antisemitic to criticise war crimes by a government which has overseen the murder of thousands of children in the space of a few weeks. In a similar vein, condemnation of the actions of Hamas should not be seen as anti-Islam.

loading
Advertisement