Advertisement

On Reflection | Remember Mao’s famine, forget Churchill’s: how the West captured Asian minds

  • History, as taught by Western ‘victors’, defines other countries through their low points. We are constantly reminded of China’s Tiananmen moment, yet colonial atrocities from First Nations genocides to Bengal’s famine are diluted or covered up
  • It is this selective retelling of history that enables the West to cling to an identity built on superiority and that has non-Westerners believing it. It is why some young Hongkongers have come to believe they are not Chinese

Reading Time:6 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
82
Demonstrators fly the British flag during the Hong Kong protests in 2019. Photo: AP
In late June and early July, First Nations communities in Canada found over 1,000 unmarked graves of children in Indian residential schools, which were run by the Roman Catholic Church from 1899 to 1997. This has led to activists burning Catholic churches and taking down statues of Queen Elizabeth II and Queen Victoria.
Advertisement
These residential schools often coercively separated First Nations children from families, forcing them to speak English and learn European curriculums. Any attempt to dress, speak, or act like a First Nations individual was punished. There were 130 schools like this, with estimates that over 6,000 children died due to poor sanitation, little protection from the cold, or abuse from school staff. Similar practices existed in Australia, where up to one in three First Nations Australian children were taken by federal, state and church education initiatives. They are collectively referred to as the Stolen Generation, and it has led to social trauma and inequality that persists today.

However, these tragic events are largely hidden in Canada’s history, and certainly from international perceptions of the country. Instead, Canada has a global reputation for being friendly and polite, and is not known for this “cultural genocide”, as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada described it in 2015.

But other countries around the world are absolutely defined by unsavoury moments in their history: global media will refer to Tiananmen Square when discussing China; to state-backed assassinations in discussions of Russia; to corrupt, incompetent leaders in African countries and dictators in Latin America.
A photo made available by the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation at the University of Manitoba shows children at the Kamloops Indian Residential School in British Columbia, Canada, in 1944. A mass grave has been located at the site of the school that contains the bodies of 215 children whose deaths went undocumented. Photo: EPA
A photo made available by the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation at the University of Manitoba shows children at the Kamloops Indian Residential School in British Columbia, Canada, in 1944. A mass grave has been located at the site of the school that contains the bodies of 215 children whose deaths went undocumented. Photo: EPA

Yet is America defined by “pioneers” destroying First Nations culture and committing genocide? No. Is Australia defined by settlers waging war on the First Nations people who until 1967 were not even considered citizens in their own country? No. Is tiny Belgium defined by its horrific colonial treatment of the population in Congo? No. The list is long.

Advertisement
Advertisement