Advertisement

Asian Angle | Restricting academics makes it harder for China to tell its own story

  • By clamping down on the freedom of scholars to have frank discussions with their Western counterparts, Beijing is copying one of the worst aspects of the Donald Trump administration
  • Hong Kong was once an escape valve for discussions on China, but the national security law has changed the atmosphere

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
30
Professor Jia Qingguo warned in March that excessive demands for permission to meet foreigners was hampering research. File photo
One of the more reckless gestures of the Donald Trump administration was its decision to restrict visas for Chinese academic visitors to the United States.
Advertisement

We’re not talking here about allowing Chinese scholars access to US physics and computing labs that some fear might mean that the latest information about AI or rocket technology might find its way to Beijing by underhand means.

Senior specialists on international relations, trade policy and Chinese politics had their multiple-entry visas revoked. Students in these areas were told they might not be able to take up their places to study.

At a time when US understanding of China was crucial, cutting off ready access to first-hand information about the place was a backwards step. Social science specialists were unlikely candidates to steal national security sensitive data. They might well have been fervent Chinese nationalists, but since that is a pretty mainstream position in China, it would have been sensible to have a few exponents of it around in the US to take part in debate (and indeed to be vigorously rebutted).
So it seems counterproductive that China now seems to be taking some of the worst aspects of the Trump policy and applying them to its own best and brightest.
Restricting Chinese academics was one of Donald Trump’s worst moves, writes Rana Mitter. Photo: Reuters
Restricting Chinese academics was one of Donald Trump’s worst moves, writes Rana Mitter. Photo: Reuters

The South China Morning Post has reported signs of the dangers in the past few months. Jia Qingguo, professor of international relations at Peking University and a delegate to the CPPCC (Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference), warned in March that excessive demands for permission to meet foreigners were hampering research.

Advertisement
Advertisement