customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

knowledgeQuestion

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Phar Kim Beng

Malaysia is stuck in the middle income trap. And one of the problems keeping it there is the massive size of its civil service – estimated at 1.6 million by Mohammad Sherif Kassim, the former secretary general of the Ministry of Finance.
While such a large service has the effect of buttressing the government, making Malaysia more stable, it also hampers efforts to transform the government, making Malaysia more stagnant too.
So while Mohammad’s desire to reduce the size of the civil service is quite understandable – indeed, it may even be necessary to prevent a government financial meltdown – Prime Minister Najib Razak knows that doing so would be the kiss of death politically, given the impending general election.
Thus Najib has taken to reassuring the civil service, which is predominantly formed of Malays, not to worry about any reduction in headcount. The can has been kicked down the road.
Najib’s take on Malaysia’s new MRT risks upsetting Chinese
It should be noted that Mohammad’s figure of 1.6 million includes armed forces, police, education and hospital personnel. The Congress of Unions of Employees in the Public and Civil Services (Cuepacs) claims that these should not be included in the headcount, as is the case in some other countries, and consequently claims the civil service numbers 500,000. Even so, there is a self-serving logic to Cuepacs’ suggestion – they don’t want their heads to roll.

However the headcount is made, the fact is the Malaysian civil service is a behemoth, one of the largest in the world.
In February 2017, the deputy finance minister, Abang Johari, warned the annual payroll was already at US$19 billion while pension payments were US$4.5 billion a year.
There is one civil servant for every 19.37 people in Malaysia, according to Johari, as opposed to 1 to 71.4 in Singapore; 1 to 110 in Indonesia; 1 to 50 in South Korea; 1 to 108 in China; 1 to 28 in Japan; 1 to 84 in Russia; and 1 to 118 in Britain.
The bloated size of Malaysia’s service causes government expenditure to rise yearly and create a government that is unwieldy and bulky.
While opposition parties like the Democratic Action Party (DAP) have voiced concern over the size of the civil service before, not even they are prepared to address the issue head on as they too are scared to lose votes. Ninety per cent of Malaysia’s civil servants are ethnic Malays.
An election like none other, is it time for change in Malaysia?
This is the demographic that the DAP and the opposition coalition have been targeting in their bid to beat Najib in the upcoming general election.
Liew Ching Tong, one of the top strategists in the DAP, believes that if the Malay votes were to dip by 15 per cent – a distinct possibility – the opposition would gain another 34 seats in parliament. This would immediately deny Najib a simple majority of 112 seats.
Given the General Election is looming – it must be called by the middle of next year – the bloated nature of the civil service has been left largely uncommented upon.

Yet, in spite of the pliant nature of the Malaysian government under Najib, there are tell tale signs that the civil service may throw their lot to the opposition anyway. These votes may well come from the armed forces and police, whose welfare and salaries remain stagnant.
Leaks against the Najib government have turned from a trickle to a torrent over the last five years.
And the Malaysian police, which has in the past appeared happy to crack down on the opposition, has begun to turn a blind eye.
Rais Hussin, the top strategist of Bersatu, which is the party of former premier Dr Mahathir Mohamad, told The Malaysian Insight that “silent support of the opposition is gaining”.
He said Malaysian civil servants were pro-Bersatu but would not declare their support openly. However, they would vote out Najib’s Umno (United Malays National Organisation) party on a secret ballot.
Can China really deliver Malaysia’s Singapore slayer?
Rais may well have a point, as the government servants fear being dismissed from their jobs.
The key question facing Najib now is fiscal management. How does he continue to pay the government employees and their pensions?
Government coffers are fast diminishing – on July 31, state investment fund 1MDB failed to make a reimbursement of US$650 million to Ipic, a sovereign wealth fund in Dubai that has lent 1MDB nearly US$6.4 billion in two loans it now wants serviced.
Najib can borrow from local banks to tide him over, but if he does this it will have the effect of “crowding out” other genuine borrowers, and the interest rate would spike.
This would lead to a vicious cycle in the economy and prompt living costs to rise.
Thus Najib is trapped. His only political lifeline is the Malaysian civil service.
If he can retain their support, and continue to attract large amounts of foreign direct investment from China, he can cling to power.

But first Malaysia must find a way around Beijing’s restrictions on how the money is spent – otherwise investments from China will cater only to Belt and Road Initiative projects.
Such a play would not be without risk, as the opposition has pointed out. If Malaysia keeps taking money from China without looking at the merits of the projects the cash is spent on, Malaysia risks becoming another Sri Lanka – which has a port managed and controlled wholly by the Chinese due to the island’s inability to repay its debt.
Why are Chinese moving to Malaysia by the thousands?
The opposition has argued, not without merit, that Malaysia under Najib stands at the precipice of just such a state of affairs if it takes a pro-China approach to the exclusion of all other investment and fiscal options provided by the international markets.
But with the albatross of 1MDB hanging on Najib’s neck – he denies being linked to a scandal at the fund in which investigators traced US$700 million into a private bank account – even the option of going global has become problematic.
Pay outs and bonuses for the Malay civil service could yet turn the situation around, but doing so would incur even greater domestic and foreign debt.


Malaysian king breaks down as he remembers dead son during talks with China’s Xi Jinping

Why did Malaysia’s Anwar Ibrahim give Russia a free pass over Ukraine?

Malaysia must tread fine line in EV push amid US-China rivalry, trade tensions: minister

‘A better bet’: Asia backs Kamala Harris over more Trump turmoil in US presidential race

Malaysia

Najib can’t afford to keep Malaysia’s civil servants – or to lose them

Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak must court the civil service vote if he is to cling to power. But its bloated nature could be financially disastrous for the country. Photo: AFP

Hospital staff wear protective mask to guard against threat of a deadly virus in Kuala Lumpur 11 April 2003. A crew member on a luxury cruise liner is suspected to have been stricken by the deadly pneumonia virus SARS while on board and has been hospitalised in Malaysia, the health ministry said Friday. AFP PHOTO/Ahmad YUSNI / AFP PHOTO / AHMAD YUSNI

Indonesian national Siti Aisyah (C) is escorted by Malaysian police after a court appearance with Vietnamese national Doan Thi Huong (not pictured) at the magistrates' court in Sepang on May 30, 2017, for their alleged role in the assassination of Kim Jong-Nam, the half-brother of North Korean leader Kim Jong-Un. Indonesian Siti Aisyah, 25, and Vietnamese Doan Thi Huong, 28, have been charged with the murder of Kim Jong-Nam, the estranged half-brother of North Korean leader Kim Jong-Un, at Kuala Lumpur International Airport in February. / AFP PHOTO / MOHD RASFAN

Supporters of Najib’s Umno party. Photo: AFP

Malaysia's Prime Minister Najib Razak (L) shakes hands with China's President Xi Jinping during the welcome ceremony for the Belt and Road Forum, at the International Conference Center in Yanqi Lake, north of Beijing, on May 15, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / POOL / Kenzaburo FUKUHARA

Why Mahathir Mohamad is Malaysia’s best hope, and Najib’s worst nightmare

Prime Minister and Umno president Najib Razak (in red) during the opening ceremony of the ruling party’s 69th general assembly in Kuala Lumpur, in December 2015. Photo: EPA

This photo dated 06 February 1997 shows Malaysian deputy Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim (L) removing a dustball from Prime Minister Mahathir's sleeve during a press conference. Mahathir has decided to take a two month break from this week. [21JUNE2015 FEATURE 3 POST MAGAZINE]

A Malaysian cosplayer dressed in a samurai costume sits between Muslim women onboard a Light Rapid Transit (LRT) train during a "Commuter Cosplay" event in Kuala Lumpur on July 8, 2017. The first event of its kind, in partnership with Malaysia's RapidKL transport, aimed at bringing cosplay out of event halls and into public spaces to highlight its positive side. / AFP PHOTO / MANAN VATSYAYANA

An election like none other, is it time for change in Malaysia?

A new coalition, a new logo, a new atmosphere of economic malaise and a new wave of young voters mean there’s virtually no point of reference this coming election

(FILES) This file picture taken on February 17, 2015 shows Nurul Izzah, the daughter of Malaysian opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, gesturing as she leaves after her father's legal case against Malaysia's foreign minister at the Duta court complex in Kuala Lumpur. The eldest daughter of Malaysian opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim said on March 16, 2015 she had been arrested for sedition after reading out in parliament parts of a speech by her father criticizing his recent jailing. AFP PHOTO / FILES /Mohd RASFAN

Malaysia's opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim speaks to the media in Kuala Lumpur February 4, 2015. REUTERS/Olivia Harris/File Photo

Former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad is pictured during an interview at his office in Kuala Lumpur, October 18, 2013. REUTERS/Samsul Said/File photo

A family have a picnic in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Photo: EPA

Malaysia's Prime Minister Najib Razak and wife Rosmah Mansor. In 2009 the leader’s wife accepted the honorific “First Lady”, a first for the nation. Photo: Reuters

If Anwar and Mahathir have kissed and made up, should Najib be worried?

Anwar Ibrahim, then deputy prime minister (right), with prime minister Mahathir Mohamad in 1997. Photo: AFP

Malaysia will have a general election some time before August 2018. Photo: AP

FILE PHOTO: Traffic passes a 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) billboard at the Tun Razak Exchange development in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, July 6, 2015. REUTERS/Olivia Harris/File Photo

FILE PHOTO - Malaysia's opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim pauses as he speaks to his assistants at a break session during his sodomy trial in Kuala Lumpur February 14, 2011. REUTERS/Bazuki Muhammad/File Photo

Mahathir Mohamad, Malaysia's former prime minister, poses for a photograph in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, on Friday, June 23, 2017. Mahathir, 91, hasn't lost any of his disdain for currency traders who drove Malaysia's economy to the brink 20 years ago. Photographer: Sanjit Das/Bloomberg

Nurul Izzah, daughter of oppression leader Anwar Ibrahim speaks to protesters as they gather to demand the freedom of Anwar, in downtown Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Saturday, March 7, 2015. Anwar began a 5-year prison sentence on Feb. 10 after being found guilty of sodomizing a former male aide in 2008. Anwar has maintained his innocence and claims he is a victim of a political vendetta by the government. (AP Photo/Vincent Thian)

epa06044763 Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak reacts after the signing ceremony between DRB-Hicom Berhad and Zhejiang Geely Holding Group at Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 23 June 2017. DRB-Hicom Berhad and Zhejiang Geely Holding Group have signed the final agreement, which sees the latter acquiring 49.99 percent of car manufacturer Proton and 51 percent of luxury sports car brand Lotus. 'Geely is a company with the right credentials and proven track record. I believe Geely has the ability and expertise to take Proton to new levels of success,' Najib Razak said on 23 June. EPA/FAZRY ISMAIL

This Week in Asia

Politics

News

Asia

Opinion

Comment

With 1.6 million on the Malaysian government’s payroll, the workers are key to electoral success. But a large service keeps the country stagnant – and prone to a financial meltdown


Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)


Column

Asian Angle

Asian Angle | Najib can’t afford to keep Malaysia’s civil servants – or to lose them

With 1.6 million on the Malaysian government’s payroll, the workers are key to electoral success. But a large service keeps the country stagnant – and prone to a financial meltdown

Najib’s take on Malaysia’s new MRT risks upsetting Chinese