Advertisement

On Balance | US must target Big Food and insurance industry to fix its healthcare

The only positive likely to come out of the killing of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO is a national conversation about why US healthcare is so bad

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
People walk past a poster outside the Hilton hotel near the scene where Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, was shot dead in midtown Manhattan, in New York, on December 5. Photo: Reuters

Political factions in the United States have argued about healthcare for decades. Like most others, this debate has become increasingly bitter over the years.

Advertisement
With the shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson – who was reportedly gunned down with bullets using casings inscribed with the words “delay”, “deny” and “depose” – the fractiousness appears to have turned deadly.
Whatever the outcome for the shooter – whose act should be condemned, regardless of how badly one has been treated by the health insurance industry – the killing of Thompson is likely to have only one benefit: a national conversation about why healthcare in the world’s richest country remains so problematic.
While most countries struggle to maintain a healthcare system that provides at least basic treatment for everyone, the US is unique in terms of the amount of determination needed to navigate the vagaries of health insurance coverage, especially for that vast category known as “the middle class”.

Even for those with full coverage and other hallmarks of higher socioeconomic brackets, horror stories about health insurance claims in any social setting are almost guaranteed to set off a round of one-upmanship with anecdotes of infuriating “delay” and “deny” tactics.

New York police released this photo of what they said was “the individual sought in connection to this investigation”, in connection with the killing of Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. Photo: Handout
New York police released this photo of what they said was “the individual sought in connection to this investigation”, in connection with the killing of Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. Photo: Handout
The fact that no one can know what a trip to an accident and emergency department will cost – let alone a course of chemotherapy or other, more advanced and targeted treatments that can save lives – shows insurers have got away with what few other industries have been able to manage. They enjoy a level of pricing opacity that leaves customers more vulnerable than borrowers from a loan shark.
Advertisement
Advertisement