Andrew Hammond

Opinion | Why Walz-Vance US vice-presidential debate is more than a sideshow

This debate matters, given the increased influence of the office and Donald Trump’s advanced age

Reading Time:3 minutes

Why you can trust SCMP

An image of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris is shown during an interview with Republican vice-presidential nominee J.D. Vance, in the spin room following the second presidential debate at the Pennsylvania Convention Center in Philadelphia, US, on September 10. Photo: Bloomberg

Andrew Hammond

Published: 8:30pm, 30 Sep 2024Updated: 12:09am, 1 Oct 2024

This week’s vice-presidential debate between Democratic Governor Tim Walz and Republican Senator J.D. Vance might not be as consequential as June’s match-up between US President Joe Biden and his predecessor Donald Trump. However, it could still affect November’s election and have wider global implications in the coming years.

This is not least given the possibility on the Republican side that Trump could die or become incapacitated during a second presidential term, from 2025 to 2029, given his advanced age of 78. His challenger, Vice-President Kamala Harris, is 59.

History underlines the crucial role that vice-presidents, stepping up in the way Vance might have to, have played in times of geopolitical tensions, which today include Ukraine and the Middle East. Harry Truman exemplifies this: he was vice-president from only January to April 1945 before assuming the presidency after Franklin D. Roosevelt died soon after winning his fourth election.

Within weeks of entering the top job, Truman made several highly consequential decisions, including the dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He also attended the landmark Potsdam conference with the Soviet Union and Britain to decide how to administer the defeated Nazi Germany.

In the nuclear age, the electoral stakes of selecting a deputy who is perceived to be capable of effectively assuming office is even higher. Take the example of the 2008 election when Republican nominee John McCain, then 71, made the decision to select the much younger, one-term Alaska governor Sarah Palin who was widely viewed at the time as too gaffe-prone to be a heartbeat away from the presidency.

02:07

US vice-presidential hopeful Tim Walz slammed by Trump supporters for China connection

Walz, 60, has significant experience as governor of Minnesota, and also served for more than a decade in the US House of Representatives. There are few doubts he could effectively assume the top job.