Advertisement

Opinion | Modi’s return to power would not mean the death of Indian democracy

  • There are real concerns, from the BJP’s Hindu nationalist rhetoric to media muzzling, but Modi’s likely re-election merely reflects his popularity
  • This should be a wake-up call for how the West views India. The country’s democracy is imperfect but it is more robust than might initially be perceived.

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Supporters of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party gather to greet Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a campaign roadshow for the elections in Varanasi, India, on May 13. Photo: AP
According to India’s opposition politicians, the country’s democracy is on its deathbed. Congress party chief Mallikarjun Kharge said last month that “democracy will end” if Prime Minister Narendra Modi returned to power for a third consecutive term.
Advertisement
However, as India’s seven-stage polls, the world’s largest electoral exercise, approach their climax – with the results due to be announced on June 4 – it is apparent that Indian democracy is more robust than initially perceived.
While the outcome seems a foregone conclusion – re-election for Modi and his Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) – the polls have yet thrown up a few surprises. There has been speculation that voter turnout is lower than anticipated, which has been attributed to everything from the weather to voter apathy.
The drop has not been significant, but it has been enough to fuel fears within the ruling BJP that it may not secure its targeted 370 seats (400 with coalition partners). It has also prompted BJP candidates (including Modi) to double down on the party’s divisive Hindu nationalist rhetoric.

While these developments are alarming, they also show that Indian democracy remains alive and kicking, such that the BJP does not have complete control over the narrative of Indian politics.

03:55

Online hate stokes fear among Muslims as Indian elections loom

Online hate stokes fear among Muslims as Indian elections loom
Despite the government’s ambitions to centralise power, the election has reaffirmed the idea that “all politics is local”, with regional politics and livelihood issues dominating campaigns. That recent state elections have seen fewer recounts or complaints about vote rigging or manipulation also reaffirms that Indian democracy remains intact at a procedural level.
Advertisement