bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Cannix Yau

A new section of Hong Kong’s MTR rail system opening on May 15 will allow commuters to get from parts of the New Territories to Central faster, with savings along some routes, but bus operators are dreading their loss of business.
The cross-harbour Hung Hom-Admiralty section of the Sha Tin to Central MTR link is expected to result in thousands switching from bus to rail.
The rail section, also known as the cross-harbour extension of the East Rail line, will be the fourth cross-harbour railway route directly connecting the northeastern New Territories, central Kowloon and Hong Kong Island.
It will allow commuters to reach the city’s commercial and financial hub in Wan Chai North and Admiralty without switching lines and changing trains.
What can commuters expect from cross-harbour section of Hong Kong rail link?
Raising the concerns of major bus and minibus operators, lawmaker Michael Tien Puk-sun said KMB, Citybus and New World First Bus (NWFB) expected to lose an overall daily ridership of at least 100,000 when the new section opens.
“They will suffer an exodus of passengers. Just for the Cross-Harbour Tunnel routes at Hung Hom station, the bus operators told me, they will lose 30,000 passengers every day during peak hours,” he said.
“The bus operators will suffer losses for at least five years before they can see any glimpse of hope from the new town development in Kwu Tung in 2027.”
For commuters, switching from buses and minibuses to the expanded East Rail line will be an easy choice. Travel times will be shorter and some will pay less by train than they do to take the bus along some routes.
For example, a bus ride on KMB route 673 from Sheung Shui in the New Territories to Admiralty costs HK$25.60, but MTR commuters will pay HK$21 on the East Rail line. The train trip will take just 40 minutes, compared with as much as an hour and 40 minutes by bus.

With a new signalling system, the railway will run at 2.7-minute intervals during peak hours, with journeys between Tai Wai, in the Sha Tin district of the New Territories, and Admiralty taking only 17 minutes without commuters having to change trains at an interchange, 11 minutes faster than using indirect routes.
Anticipating a significant loss of ridership, a spokeswoman for Bravo Transport Services, owner of Citybus and NWFB, said: “At present, the cross-harbour bus routes have been the main source of income of Citybus and NWFB. The cross-harbour section of the East Rail line will severely impact our revenue.”
She said they hoped to retain passengers by offering interchange discounts of HK$2 per trip on five bus routes from Exhibition Centre rail station, including a new route 1M between the station and Wong Nai Chung Gap via Happy Valley.
Citybus and NWFB have been suffering losses of around HK$25 million (US$3.2 million) a month amid the pandemic, and Bravo shareholders injected an additional HK$337 million last year to keep services running.
Citybus and NWFB account for about 30 per cent of Hong Kong’s franchised bus operations, with a 1,700-strong fleet and more than 210 routes.
A KMB spokeswoman said the company had asked the Transport Department for a review of bus routes between New Territories East and Kowloon, including four which would be hit the hardest by the new rail extension.
Cross-harbour section of Hong Kong rail link to fully open on May 15
KMB, the city’s largest franchised bus operator, manages more than 420 routes with an average daily ridership of 2.44 million and made a net profit of HK$101.4 million last year.
Lawmaker Tien, former chairman of the Kowloon-Canton Railway Corporation (KCRC), said bus operators had to explore new routes in new towns or housing estates without nearby rail stations, and ask the Transport Department to reduce some bus services to rein in costs.
He expected bus companies to rebound in five years, when the first phase of the Kwu Tung new town development in Fanling, in the New Territories, was expected to be completed, with a population of more than 110,000. Other new town projects would follow.
“By that time the East Rail line will be overcrowded and passengers may turn to buses again to go to Kowloon and Hong Kong,” he said.
Chau Kwok-keung, chairman of the Hong Kong Taxi and Public Light Bus Association, said minibuses took a beating when the MTR’s Tuen Ma line opened in June last year, with routes between Hung Hom and Mong Kok or Kowloon City hit hard.
The opening of the new cross-harbour rail line would hit them again, he said. The city has about 4,228 minibuses.

Chau urged the Transport Department to take back 21 bus routes being run by the rail operator, the MTR Corporation, and hand them to minibuses to operate.
“There is no need for the MTR Corp to run bus routes,” he said.
Quentin Cheng Hin-kei, spokesman of the commuter concern group Public Transport Research Team, agreed the rail extension was a good thing for commuters but was concerned about the healthy overall development of public transport.
If people flocked to the MTR, he said, the rail system would be overloaded. The city needed a diversified public transport service to cater to the different needs of people, and he pointed out that buses had some advantages over trains.
“The good thing about buses is their comfort and convenience,” he said.
Acknowledging the impact of the new rail link on buses, especially those run by Citybus and NWFB, he said the government could help by subsidising underused bus routes.
“Apart from exploring new routes in new towns, the Transport Department should allocate some KMB routes to Citybus and NWFB to raise their competitiveness,” he said.
Hong Kong to get first electric double-decker bus designed for hilly terrain
The department said it anticipated commuters’ travelling patterns and demand would change significantly with the opening of the cross-harbour rail section.
As a result, it was cancelling cross-harbour bus route 301 from May 15, and would also consider scrapping special departure bus services at the Cross-Harbour Tunnel in phases.
“The Transport Department will also closely monitor the operation of relevant franchised bus services … and make suitable service adjustments subject to actual passenger demand, so as to achieve more effective use of public transport resources, enhance service network efficiency and improve service quality,” it said.


Hong Kong’s MTR Corp won’t use by-laws to force travellers to stand on both sides of escalators

Walk this way? Why Hong Kong’s MTR Corp is targeting escalator etiquette

Hong Kong to deploy tens of thousands to test crowd control at Kai Tak stadium

Walk in the park? Why it takes 1 hour to get from Hong Kong’s Kai Tak stadium to TST

MTR Corporation

New Hong Kong cross-harbour rail link a boon for commuters, but bus operators expect big loss of passengers

The Sha Tin to Central rail link. Photo: Sam Tsang

The construction site of the Exhibition Centre station. Photo: Sam Tsang

Passengers queue up for buses to Hong Kong Island at the Hung Hom Cross – Harbour Tunnel bus station. Photo: Winson Wong

What can commuters expect from cross-harbour section of Hong Kong’s most expensive rail project when it opens on May 15?

The newly built Exhibition Centre station. Photo: Sam Tsang

Admiralty station is among the stops for the Sha Tin to Central link. Photo: Sam Tsang

Admiralty station will become a mega interchange station of four railway lines – East Rail line, Tsuen Wan line, Island line and South Island line. Photo: Sam Tsang

The MTR says the expanded East Rail line will have sufficient capacity to cope with the rise in passenger demand. Photo: Dickson Lee

A trip between Hung Hom station (pictured) and Exhibition Centre will cost HK$10.1. Photo: Sam Tsang

“Mapping Our Way”, a suspended sculpture designed by American artist Talley Fisher, at Admiralty station. Photo: Sam Tsang

‘End of an era’ for Hong Kong MTR’s cross-border through-train services with Guangzhou, Beijing, Shanghai

An inter-city through train run by the MTR. Photo: Handout

Through train services from Hong Kong have been running for more than a century. Photo: May Tse

A train arrives at a station in Hung Hom in 1979. 

Hong Kong to get first electric double-decker bus designed to handle hilly terrain in move towards carbon neutrality

Bravo Transport’s battery-powered double-decker bus can handle hilly terrain and accommodate 113 passengers. Photo: Jonathan Wong

Quality control supervisor Chan Kwoon-yui shows the electric battery modules located on the lower deck of the bus. Photo: Jonathan Wong

The electric bus is designed with Hong Kong’s road and weather conditions in mind. Photo: Jonathan Wong

Hong Kong’s costliest rail project hit by more delays, with July next year new target date for opening Hung Hom-Admiralty section

The MTR Corporation had been evasive about whether it would complete the section on time. Photo: Felix Wong

General view of the Sha Tin to Central rail link at Hung Hom MTR station, Hung Hom. 12MAY20 SCMP / Nora Tam

Dr Jacob Kam Chak-pui, Chief Executive Officer of MTR Corporation Limited, attends the companies’ Interim Results 2019, Wan Chai. 08AUG19 SCMP / Winson Wong

Hong Kong’s MTR Corporation set to freeze ticket prices this year, with 3.8 per cent fare rebate set to be extended

The last time the MTR Corporation raised fares was in 2019, by 3.3 per cent. Photo: Sam Tsang

News

Hong Kong

Transport


East Rail line MTR extension will cut travel time from New Territories, with fare savings for some
Bus, minibus operators brace themselves for ‘exodus’ of passengers, hope for review of routes



Bus operators brace themselves for ‘exodus’ of passengers as East Rail line MTR extension will cut travel time from New Territories.


Transport and logistics

New World First Bus

New Hong Kong cross-harbour rail link a boon for commuters, but bus operators expect big loss of passengers

East Rail line MTR extension will cut travel time from New Territories, with fare savings for some Bus, minibus operators brace themselves for ‘exodus’ of passengers, hope for review of routes

East Rail line MTR extension will cut travel time from New Territories, with fare savings for some

Bus, minibus operators brace themselves for ‘exodus’ of passengers, hope for review of routes