Advertisement

Hong Kong officials ‘gain points’ for shelving waste-charging scheme but saga exposes policy execution gaps, analysts say

  • Central government will probably advise John Lee to tread carefully even on seemingly ‘trivial’ practical matters, veteran political analyst says
  • Shelving controversial scheme seems to be the wisest and most politically cost-effective way to handle situation, another academic says

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
19
The waste-charging scheme, first floated about 20 years ago, has been repeatedly pushed back. Photo: Eugene Lee
Hong Kong leader John Lee Ka-chiu’s administration has won praise for being politically wise in suspending a controversial waste-charging scheme amid opposition from various sectors but analysts have also warned the saga has exposed inadequacies in policy execution.
Advertisement

Veteran China watcher Professor Lau Siu-kai on Monday also said he believed Beijing might seek to micromanage more and could take a closer look at the government’s opinion gathering and analysis ability in the days to come.

At a Legislative Council panel meeting on Monday, Deputy Chief Secretary Warner Cheuk Wing-hing said the waste-charging scheme would not be implemented on August 1 as scheduled.

The decision was made, Cheuk said, after various surveys revealed the public had huge reservations, pointing to limited coverage of recycling facilities.

Lau said: “I think the incident will dent the government’s authority a little bit. But I do not think it will be too severe since the scheme has not yet been implemented.

Advertisement

“The government might gain some points because of its willingness to change course amid public opposition.”

Advertisement