Advertisement

It's high time to reasonably adjust our disability laws

Recent comments from Richard Dawkins highlight a hole in our civil rights protections

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Simon Ng is an assistant professor and senior programme director of law at the School of Professional and Continuing Education, University of Hong Kong.

The prominent Oxford scientist Richard Dawkins recently issued a controversial tweet advising a woman to "abort it and try again" if she was pregnant with a baby with Down's syndrome. He said "it would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice".

Advertisement

The tweet caused a storm on social media, and Dawkins was forced to apologise.

Even though genetics and science can reveal impairments and limitations, they aren't good predictors of life.

Recently I read a feature about Chris Burke, the celebrated American actor with Down's syndrome. I also recall another story of a talented girl with Down's syndrome, Bryann Burgess, who qualified as a music teacher after undergoing a course of study and an internship at South Carolina University. I wonder what Dawkins would say about them.

The world has a wealth of talented "disabled" people. The famous animal science professor Dr Temple Grandin, who has autism, was once misdiagnosed as unteachable. But she turned her picture-based thinking into an asset in her career.

Advertisement

Stephen Wiltshire, the artist who has a gift in drawing life-like, detailed cityscapes after brief observations, is autistic and had no language until the age of nine. Queen Elizabeth awarded him an MBE in 2006.

There is also a non-verbal, autistic young gentleman, Brad Fremmerlid, who has a special talent for putting furniture together and has a small business in Edmonton, Canada.

Advertisement