Advertisement

Blindsided: why does Beijing keep getting Hong Kong wrong?

  • In a series of in-depth articles on the unrest rocking Hong Kong, the Post goes behind the headlines to look at the underlying issues, current state of affairs and where it is all heading
  • Here, we look at how Beijing fails to grasp the sentiment of the city

Reading Time:7 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Brian Wang

Hong Kong businessman Sam Tsang does not like to talk politics. As a senior business consultant who travels frequently to mainland China and Taiwan, he knows silence is often golden.

Advertisement

He was in for a shock when, one night in mid-July, his boss introduced him to two “mainland researchers” who were visiting Hong Kong. That evening, all they talked about was politics.

It was just two weeks after the storming of Hong Kong’s Legislative Council chamber by young protesters, angry at the government’s controversial proposal to allow transfers of criminal suspects to mainland China, and at the excessive force they felt police had used to quell previous protests against the now-abandoned extradition bill.

“They asked a lot of questions about the anti-extradition bill protests,” Tsang said. “They wanted to know why Hong Kong people were so angry. Why did we hate Carrie Lam and the police so much, etc? I told them I’m an apolitical person and cannot represent anyone. Still, they were interested.”

Young protesters storm Hong Kong’s Legislative Council on July 1. The scale of the city’s anti-government sentiment has taken Beijing by surprise. Photo: Sam Tsang
Young protesters storm Hong Kong’s Legislative Council on July 1. The scale of the city’s anti-government sentiment has taken Beijing by surprise. Photo: Sam Tsang
Advertisement

Tsang said the two mainlanders – who only told him vaguely that they “worked for the central government” – even showed him some excerpts from their previous reports to Beijing.

“In the end, I could not bite my tongue and asked them ‘how could you have got things so wrong?’”

SCMP Series
[ 5 of 17 ]
Advertisement