Advertisement

How Asia sees Carrie Lam’s withdrawal of Hong Kong extradition bill: ‘It’s welcome, but …’

  • Protesters in Hong Kong may have been scathing about the chief executive’s attempt to appease the public; regional leaders have been a little more supportive
  • But most welcomes have been both cautious and qualified

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Many Hongkongers have been unmoved by Carrie Lam’s U-turn on the extradition bill. Photo: Robert Ng
Hong Kong’s protest movement may be unimpressed with Carrie Lam’s decision to formally withdraw the extradition bill that sparked three months of social unrest, but regional leaders appear a little more supportive of her attempts to appease the public.
Advertisement

Initial hopes for a breakthrough following the climbdown by the city’s embattled chief executive, announced on Wednesday, were tempered when protesters derided it as like putting a “Band-Aid on rotting flesh” and vowed to continue demonstrating until she gives into the rest of their five demands. Their four remaining conditions are: withdrawing the characterisation of the protests as “riots”; amnesty for all protesters; an independent investigation into the police’s use of force; and universal suffrage.

Embattled: Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam. Photo: Sam Tsang
Embattled: Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam. Photo: Sam Tsang

But if protesters locally are largely displeased with Lam’s announcement – on Thursday she was even moved to hold a press conference to emphasise the decision was her own and not that of Beijing – some of her counterparts have given her announcement a cautious – but qualified – welcome.

In Australia, foreign affairs minister Marise Payne welcomed Lam’s announcement as a positive step in dealing with the concerns of protesters.

“We encourage any efforts to resolve the situation in Hong Kong peacefully,” she told local press on Thursday. “We continue to urge further efforts to de-escalate, establish dialogue and commit to negotiation as a basis for a lasting resolution.”

Advertisement