bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

knowledgeQuestion

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Digitalisation has transformed many aspects of our lives, including the realm of sleep.
Sleep apps, white-noise devices and other digital sleep aids are supposed to make falling asleep easier and our sleep sounder.
But can they really help remedy sleep disorders?
Take sleep trackers, for instance. If you’ve got a smartwatch or fitness tracker, you can use it to gather information on the quality of your sleep.
“The existence of sleep trackers is fundamentally a good thing because they heighten awareness that sleep has a very important biological function,” says Dr Hans-Günter Weess, head of the Interdisciplinary Sleep Centre at the Palatinate Clinic for Psychiatry and Neurology, in Germany.

Sleep is the body’s most important regeneration and repair programme, he says, but then takes closer aim at sleep trackers.
“Most sleep trackers, sorry to say, are very imprecise. They measure neither sleep quality nor sleep duration accurately,” he says, adding that most have also not been scientifically tested.
The trackers are based on “Stone Age methods” of sleep research, he says, and often measure only the frequency of movement, time and user’s heart rate. Consequently, they can provide false results, and perhaps detect no sleep disorder when one is actually present.
How antidepressants, sleeping pills and other drugs raise dementia risk
There’s another drawback: people with a sleep disorder are particularly anxious about their sleep. Measuring it focuses them even more on their trouble sleeping – a vicious circle.
The more preoccupied you are with your insomnia, the more tense and restless you’ll be – and less likely to sleep well.
“Tension is the enemy of sleep,” Weess says. “People are able to sleep only when they’re not fretting about their everyday concerns and whether they’ll be able to sleep.”
He advises his patients to avoid the devices and rely on their own body awareness.

There are other technological sleep aids, such as metronome lights, that project a gently pulsating blue light onto the ceiling. If you synchronise your breathing with the light’s slow expansion and contraction, it will purportedly relax your mind and slow down both your breathing and heart rate.
White noise can have a calming effect too – that is, a monotonous sound experienced as pleasant, such as ocean waves or leaves rustling in the wind. There are stand-alone devices, apps and internet videos that produce white noise.
“Many of these digital sleep aids are meant to relax users and help them to better manage their mental, emotional or physical restlessness,” Weess says.
How brown noise can help with ADHD and let your newborn sleep better
They’re rarely effective for people with a severe sleep disorder though, he points out, noting that only 1 to 2 per cent of his patients use white noise to help them sleep.
He cautions that the supposed effectiveness of most digital sleep aids isn’t backed by studies.
“They’ve got a hi-tech flair that gives the impression of scientificity,” he says, adding they can be quite expensive too.
In order for us to sleep, our nervous system has to switch from stress-and-performance mode to relaxation-and-rest mode
Sleep coach Jan Herzog
Dr Thomas Penzel, scientific director of the Interdisciplinary Sleep Medicine Centre at Charité University Hospital in Berlin, affirms that very few digital sleep aids have been scientifically tested. An exception, he says, is Somnio, a digital health app for the treatment of sleep-onset and sleep maintenance insomnia.
Created by a German developer and distributor of digital medical products, it’s available on prescription in Germany. A study has shown that it can help remedy insomnia.
According to Penzel, the app mainly provides sleep hygiene rules – for example, maintain a regular bedtime and rise time, and keep your bedroom and workspace separate – in combination with consultation.
“Sleep isn’t something you can simply switch on – it’s a behaviour,” he says. “You’ve got to try to reduce stress and relax before you go to bed.”

Digital sleep aids can though be useful when part of a relaxing bedtime ritual, Penzel says. For some people the ritual is reading, for others a glass of warm milk, subdued lighting or white noise.
“Whatever calms you down is positive,” he says. “So you can’t say that all these gadgets are rubbish. If they’re used to bolster a [bedtime] ritual, then yes, they can help.”
Sleep coach Jan Herzog takes a similar view: “These tools don’t enable someone with a genuine sleep disorder to fall asleep quicker and sleep more soundly,” he says, although he does allow that in individual cases they can help a person to relax.
“In order for us to sleep, our nervous system has to switch from stress-and-performance mode to relaxation-and-rest mode,” he explains.

What truly helps to relieve insomnia, he says, is dealing with your worries and fears during the day so that they don’t keep you up at night.
“You should write down the three things currently causing you the most stress, and three ways to solve them. Then you won’t have to occupy your mind with them in the last 20 minutes of the day,” Herzog says.
In cases of severe sleep disorders, specialised cognitive behaviour therapy can help, Weess says.
“It’s always better when patients learn to be their own sleeping pill,” he says. “That means they learn how to enter a sleep-inducing state of relaxation and calm on their own, and not by taking a medication or using a technical aid.”


How a former bellhop went on to run the No 5 hotel on The World’s 50 Best Hotels 2024, The Upper House in Hong Kong

What to eat during perimenopause, Gwyneth Paltrow’s diet, and experts’ 5 dietary tips

Scenes of alcohol drinking in K-dramas and viral YouTube chat shows draw fire in Korea

Splash for cash: how domestic helper gives back to Hong Kong charity in 45km swim relay at sea

Wellness

Can sleep trackers and white noise apps really help you slumber? Experts explain

White noise apps, sleep trackers and other digital sleep aids are becoming more popular as people turn to tech to help them sleep, but do they really work? Photo: Shutterstock

Most sleep trackers are very imprecise, Dr Hans-Günter Weess says. Photo: Shutterstock

The Dodow sleep aid device is a metronome light that teaches you how to fall asleep naturally. Photo: Dodow

A study has shown that the Somnio sleep tracker can help remedy insomnia. Photo: Somnio

Dealing with your worries and fears during the day can help relieve insomnia at night, sleep coach Jan Herzog says. Photo: Shutterstock

5 tips to become fitter, healthier and happier than ever, from an expat who transformed her body and mind in Malaysia

Lise Poulsen Floris on Mount Kinabalu, the highest mountain in Borneo and Malaysia, at sunrise. Conquering the mountain has been part of her journey to becoming a fitter, healthier and happier person. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Poulsen Floris takes first in her age category at her first triathlon, in Malaysia. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Poulsen Floris’ cycling group “Bike in Nature” on Malaysia’s jungle roads. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Poulsen Floris shows off her Mount Kinabalu tattoo, done in Borneo to celebrate climbing the mountain. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Floris Poulsen attends a sound healing workshop with friends. Photo: Lise Floris Poulsen

A reiki course with Melani Koch at The Yoga Barn in Bali. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Poulsen Floris and her husband celebrate his birthday with alcohol-free champagne. Photo: Lise Floris Poulsen

The first “Classy AF” alcohol-free cocktail-making masterclass in Kuala Lumpur. Photo: Lise Poulsen Floris

Headaches, stiff neck? Maybe you have a brain aneurysm. A neurologist explains what to look out for

A brain aneurysm occurs when there is a bulge in a weak area of an artery in the brain. A ruptured aneurysm can also cause people to experience extremely painful headaches, nausea, vomiting, stiff neck, blurry vision or a serious loss of consciousness. Photo: Getty Images

Shailja Ambrose (left) with her younger sister, Neerja Patel. After Ambrose’s shock ruptured brain aneurysm, Patel was screened and learned she had not one but three brain aneurysms. Photo: Courtesy of Shailja Ambrose

Surgeons perform surgery to treat a brain aneurysm. Photo: Getty Images

New York neurosurgeon Dr Omar Syed recommends an annual MRI screening if two or more first-degree relatives have had aneurysms. Photo: Metropolitan Neurosurgery Associates

Lifestyle

Gadgets

Health & Wellness

Sleep trackers, white-noise apps and other digital sleep aids are supposed to make falling asleep easier and our sleep better, but experts are not so convinced
They agree that while the technology has its uses, most important is for people to learn how to relax and to rely on their own body awareness


Sleep trackers, white-noise devices and other digital sleep aids and apps are supposed to make falling asleep easier and our sleep better, but experts are not so convinced.


Wearables

Technology

How to age well

Apps