Advertisement

Is Hong Kong ‘fiddling while Rome burns’ on fire safety? Lessons from deadly Ngau Tau Kok fire

Crackdown on safety of mini storage facilities is all very well, but last year’s tragedy exposed fire prevention failings that affect many privately owned buildings, say safety experts

Reading Time:5 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Two firefighters lost their lives in the blaze broke out at Amoycan Industrial Centre in Ngau Tau Kok last June. Photo: Felix Wong

For every month, two people were killed by fire in Hong Kong last year, and statistics show the numbers of deaths and injuries have not been falling. Two of the lives lost were firefighters tackling the June blaze in a Ngau Tau Kok industrial building, which started in a mini storage unit.

Advertisement

Given the statistics, some observers fear the recent announcement of stricter control of mini storage outlets amounts to little more than “fiddling while Rome burns”.

Firemen survey the damage at the site of the fire in Ngau Tau Kok last June. Photo: Sam Tsang
Firemen survey the damage at the site of the fire in Ngau Tau Kok last June. Photo: Sam Tsang
“The tragic double fatality last year was truly shocking, and it highlighted to me potential problems,” says David Townsend, manager of Andrew Moore & Associates’ group fire response and investigation services.

Hong Kong-based Townsend has 30 years of experience as a firefighter and fire investigator, and he is not the only one with grave professional concerns.

Advertisement

“It’s good to see the work being done on mini storage units, but what about supermarkets or sub-divided apartments?” asks John Herbert, who operates a building services engineering consultancy and has more than 20 years of experience in fire prevention and safety systems in the city.

“The Ngau Tau Kok disaster just demonstrated that FSD [Fire Services Department] had never been inside these buildings to see what was going on,” he says, exposing a potential flaw in fire safety management in the city.

Advertisement