Advertisement

Opinion | As war in Ukraine and Gaza rage on, can the US afford to take on China?

  • Given its commitment in Eastern Europe and the Middle East, it is unclear how the United States can also sustain its rivalry with China
  • Amid rising tensions in the South China Sea, frontline treaty allies such as the Philippines have grounds to worry about how ‘ironclad’ the relationship is

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
43
Illustration: Craig Stephens

“The United States defence agreement with the Philippines is ironclad,” declared US President Joseph Biden amid rising tensions in the South China Sea. “Any attack on the Filipino aircraft, vessels or armed forces will invoke our mutual defence treaty with the Philippines.”

Advertisement
Biden’s comments came after collisions between Philippine and Chinese vessels near the Second Thomas Shoal, a contested feature where a detachment of Filipino soldiers have been precariously stationed on a dilapidated vessel.
While it was meant to project strength and reassure an Asian ally, Biden’s tough talk belies the precariousness of America’s strategic position in the world’s most dynamic region. Given that it is deeply involved in the conflict in Eastern Europe and becoming increasingly entangled in tensions in the Middle East, it’s unclear how the United States can also sustain its rivalry with an ascendant China.

Economically, the Biden administration is yet to present a credible alternative to Beijing’s mega development initiative in Asia. Geopolitically, fear of strategic abandonment is gaining ground in the region, while China is well-placed to steal the march on the US.

After almost a century of global preponderance, America is facing the real prospect of “imperial overstretch”. As historian Paul Kennedy warned, great powers can decline and fall when the cost of maintaining their primacy outweighs their actual resources.

Advertisement

Like few contemporary leaders, Biden views his presidency in grand historical terms. He has also been compared with famous past American leaders. Amid the escalating conflict in the Middle East, Biden has channelled wartime presidents such as Woodrow Wilson, who sought to “make the world safe for democracy”, and Franklin D. Roosevelt, who famously described America as an “arsenal of democracy”.

Advertisement