Advertisement

Opinion | What the US narrative on Hong Kong leaves out, and simply gets wrong

  • Viewed through a narrow anti-China lens, Hong Kong’s rights are being taken away by an autocratic ruler
  • But there is another version of events, in which Hongkongers continue to enjoy relative freedom while welcoming the return of peace and stability

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
25
US President Joe Biden hosts a virtual democracy summit at the White House in Washington on December 9, 2021. Photo: AFP

The US is using Hong Kong’s national security law as another battlefront in its anti-China crusade, and this is causing distress to countries trying to stay out of the fight.

Advertisement
The latest salvo was fired last month when the US Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC) urged President Joe Biden to “consider targeting additional sanctions to those engaged in political prosecutions in Hong Kong”.

In the CECC’s version of events, President Xi Jinping is portrayed as an autocratic ruler bent on quashing democracy by packing Hong Kong dissidents off to prisons, or worse, to be tortured in mainland China.

This narrative, like all others from the US, is formulated through the prism of a liberal democratic value system. This is understandable, given that such values make up America’s ideological DNA, and are part of a wider US-led Western campaign against autocracy.

However, each country has its own DNA, and no one country has a monopoly on values. Nor are relationships between different value systems necessarily always binary in nature.

Advertisement

An understanding of Hong Kong’s storied past is crucial for a balanced appreciation of its current predicament. The political arguments have been well covered by the media, but less so is the impact of US politics on ordinary Hong Kong people who are trying to lead normal, honest lives.

Advertisement