Advertisement

China need not choose between an open economy and national security

  • Developments in December reflect the tension between China’s moves towards allowing more foreign direct investment and concerns about national security
  • If outside forces respect China’s sensitivities and cease unnecessary insults, the country could reform better

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
13
Balloons fly past the national flag at the end of a military parade at Tiananmen Square in Beijing on October 1, 2019, to mark the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China. Photo: AFP
In December, China outlined new national security rules on foreign direct investment and agreed on an investment treaty with the European Union. On New Year’s Eve, Hainan announced a list of hitherto closed business sectors that would be opened up to foreign investment.
Advertisement

These developments are neither nationalistic nor protectionist, showing that China can ensure national security while maintaining an open economy. After all, its one-party political system is actualised more by a keen sense of its exceptional history than Leninist ideology.

Since Chinese President Xi Jinping took office, his administration has taken significant steps to improve the country. For example, it abolished the 2,000-year-old salt tax system, a symbolic crossing of the Rubicon in economy policy. And Beijing has established diplomatic relations with the Vatican after coming to an agreement on the appointment of bishops. 

The new national security rules on FDI seek to replace guanxi-based approval processes with a professional system. Guanxi, the system of personal connections, is to the modern economy what barter was to trade – both are inadequate.

Guanxi rules certainly harm China’s rise and its ability to lead, especially the developing world, to avoid an international rat race down the bottom. The lack of good legal and other professionals is a real obstacle to an open economy and against the country’s interests.

Advertisement
Tourists flock to the promenade on the Bund along the Huangpu River in Shanghai, seen against the skyline of the Lujiazui financial district, in May 2018. Photo: AFP
Tourists flock to the promenade on the Bund along the Huangpu River in Shanghai, seen against the skyline of the Lujiazui financial district, in May 2018. Photo: AFP
Advertisement