Advertisement
Inside Out & Outside In
OpinionComment
David Dodwell
David Dodwell

Protests in Hong Kong and abroad show the destructive power of deep divisions

  • Police across the globe have come under fire for the use of excessive force in the face of peaceful protests and their own blundering lack of moderation
  • Restoring trust in our communities’ legal and political institutions and promoting tolerance and cooperation are crucial to healing wounds

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A man kicks a statue of Christopher Columbus after it was pulled down by Native American activists at the State Capitol in Saint Paul, Minnesota, on June 10. Photo: DPA
David Dodwell

For most of last year, as Hong Kong’s angst-ridden youth waged a traumatising street-level drama over our present and future relationship with mainland China, youngsters across the rest of the planet danced to a different tune, galvanised by climate change. Our local trauma distracted our community from what I believed – and still believe – is the world’s most pressing challenge.

Advertisement
But all of a sudden, as the Covid-19 pandemic haunts the planet, agendas have morphed and in peculiar ways have dangerously converged. Hong Kong protests over the extradition bill and European youth protests over climate change have been put to one side. For the extradition bill, I hope this is permanent; for climate change, hopefully temporary.

In their place, grievances have converged, strongly stirred by livelihood challenges created during the 2008 global financial crisis. They are taking shape around long-festering race and class discrimination as vulnerable and minority communities have felt more than their fair share of harm from Covid-19 and the economic pain it has created.

Police across the world have come under attack for excessive use of force in the face of largely peaceful protests. They have become victims of their own blundering lack of moderation and a steep collapse in communities’ trust in legal and political institutions.

Look at the work of the International Justice Mission on the abuse of police power, or of academics such as Silvia Staubli at the University of Fribourg in Switzerland. It is clear public that trust in police is hard-wired with public trust in our leaders and community institutions. Whatever is said in Alabama or Minneapolis about reform, police will remain stuck between a rock and a hard place without higher levels of trust in our leaders.

01:22

Anti-racism and police brutality protests put UK’s black officers in tough spot

Anti-racism and police brutality protests put UK’s black officers in tough spot
The anger and violence in the United States over persistent racial abuse and police discrimination has had the peculiar effect of shifting focus away from China and its authoritarian rule to the US and its unresolved history of slavery.
Advertisement