bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Phil C. W. Chan

Wilson Leung

Someone has finally died.
Although circumstances surrounding 22-year-old university student Chow Tsz-lok’s fall at a Tseung Kwan O car park on November 4 are still unclear, there had always been a sense of inevitability that a tragedy of this nature would take place after five months of unrest in Hong Kong.
As Hongkongers mourn the death of someone so young, we must also mourn what our city has become. While Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor and her team of political yes-men emphasise the impact of the protests on our city’s economy, tout President Xi Jinping’s continued support for her administration and condemn protesters as the “enemy of the people”, the ugliness of our government and police force is on full display.
We have a police force that includes a frontline officer who would open a bottle of champagne to celebrate Chow’s death. This is the same police force that has on more than one occasion treated fire and ambulance services with disdain.
After tearfully telling Hongkongers of her motherly sacrifices for Hong Kong in a live televised interview on June 12, and consoling a vandalised MTR turnstile the day following the September 8 march where protesters implored the United States Congress to pass its Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act, Lam has not visited any of the injured protesters – or Chow’s bereaved family – and remains completely unmoved by Hongkongers’ demands for government and police accountability, as well as universal suffrage.


Instead of measures that might help calm Hongkongers’ anger after Chow’s death, we have seen an upsurge of police violence. In the morning of November 11, a traffic police officer, unencumbered by any self-restraint, fired, without warning, live rounds at unarmed protesters at close range, critically wounding one.
Meanwhile, three pro-democracy legislators were arrested on November 9, the day after Chow died, with another four told they would be arrested for interfering with a Legislative Council committee meeting on May 11 on Lam’s extradition bill that plunged our city into the abyss. A number of pro-democracy candidates for the district council election s on November 24 have also been arrested for a range of offences.
Our universities are no longer battlegrounds where people with different beliefs fight with ideas. The police, protesters and students now resort to violence on university campuses, some resembling war zones.
Hong Kong universities need to have a proper conversation about China
University administrators and academics, fearing their career prospects might be undermined, continue to be largely silent over government and police actions beyond uttering platitudes. Our universities’ places on international rankings belie their failures and complicity in Hong Kong’s worst post-war catastrophe. Sun Yat-sen would turn in his grave at what his alma mater has become.
The current and former vice-chancellors of Chinese University at last tried to speak up for their students in the evening of November 12 in a stand-off reminiscent of the Balkans in the 1990s. Police response: firing tear gas in the current vice-chancellor’s close vicinity. As the saying goes, one is not a Hongkonger if one hasn’t inhaled tear gas.




The independence of our judiciary, the greatest hallmark that distinguishes Hong Kong from mainland China, is guaranteed under Articles 2, 19 and 85  of the Hong Kong Basic Law. Yet Beijing has admonished our judges to take “common responsibility” with the executive and legislative branches to uphold law and order.
The message from the north is clear: judges must impose the severest sentences on protesters, and grant any injunctions the government and police desire. Such “common responsibility” is compulsory in a country where judges follow party edicts, not in a city where they check and balance abuse of public powers, and hold the government and police accountable.
Hong Kong has no future if independent judiciary is undermined
Amid the chaos across Hong Kong, all that Lam could muster to tell us was that her administration would not yield to protesters’ violent actions, and the Independent Police Complaints Council was well-placed to look into any complaints the public might bring against the police. Even the panel of international experts whom Lam appointed in September to advise the council disagrees.
Lam needs reminding that she did not yield after a million Hongkongers took to the street peacefully on June 9 to demand that her administration listen and withdraw her extradition bill. Lam is the fuel that literally keeps Hong Kong burning.

One does wonder if increased police violence and arrests of pro-democracy legislators and electoral candidates have been intended to fan the flames and pave the way for the district council elections to be postponed, if not cancelled altogether. The elections are extremely important for at least three reasons.
First, they represent the first opportunity for Hongkongers to voice our opinions in the ballot box since the extradition bill saga.
Second, elected members of councils for Hong Kong’s 18 districts nominate and vote on five of the 35 functional constituency members in the Legislative Council otherwise returned by restricted franchise.
Third, and most significantly, 117 members of the 1,200-member Election Committee, which selects Hong Kong’s chief executive, are drawn from elected district council members, and they might be able collectively to prevent a candidate favoured by Beijing from reaching a majority.
November’s elections will show how much Hong Kong has changed
Without shame, politicians from pro-establishment parties, expecting to face huge losses, are warning about the prospects of a “constitutional crisis” and floating suggestions that the elections should not take place as scheduled. They seem to have completely forgotten that it is their enabling of Lam that caused and continues the crisis facing Hong Kong. People’s Daily, a mouthpiece for Beijing, has since called “return to peace” a prerequisite to “fair elections”.
Postponing or cancelling the elections will be the final act of betrayal that Lam can commit against Hong Kong and Hongkongers. It is what tin-pot dictators in war-torn African countries do to cling to power. Hong Kong will truly be in ruins and all hell will break loose, from which our city will never recover.
Phil C.W. Chan is senior fellow at the Institute for Security and Development Policy. He holds law degrees from HKU, Durham and the National University of Singapore, and is author of the book China, State Sovereignty and International Legal Order. Wilson Leung is a practising barrister in Hong Kong, and holds degrees in philosophy and political science from LSE and MIT


How did judges decide prison sentences handed down in Hong Kong 47 trial?

Subversion sentences close difficult chapter as Hong Kong rule of law prevails

US threatens sanctions: what Hong Kong can expect after the jailing of 45 activists

Car hits children outside school, toxic smog crisis can be seen from space: 6 of our latest news videos

Hong Kong protests

Carrie Lam has lit Hong Kong ablaze. A failure to hold district council elections would be the final betrayal

Illustration: Craig Stephens

An anti-government protester walks past a burning vehicle during a protest in Tseung Kwan O, Hong Kong, China November 11, 2019. REUTERS/Tyrone Siu

As violence escalates, put public safety first

Firefighters help an old person as train services are suspended, leaving dozens of stranded commuters to walk after trains are stopped by objects thrown on the tracks near Sha Tin MTR Station yesterday. Photo: Winson Wong

Reconciliation needs dialogue, but first the violence must end

A police officer (left) fired three live shots in Sai Wan Ho on Monday morning. Photo: Nora Tam

As Hong Kong’s protests rage on, Xi Jinping’s meeting with Carrie Lam and China’s fourth plenum promise more interference

Demonstrators march during a protest against a proposed extradition law in Hong Kong, China, on Sunday, June 9, 2019. Hong Kong's Beijing-backed government faced new pressure to withdraw legislation easing extraditions to China after as many as 1 million people turned out to oppose the measure. Photographer: Justin Chin/Bloomberg

Opinion

Comment

News

Hong Kong


Carrie Lam, and the pro-Beijing politicians who enabled her, should not forget their responsibility for the protest chaos
If elections do not happen as scheduled, the increased violence will take a toll that the city will not recover from



Carrie Lam, and the pro-Beijing politicians who enabled her, should not forget their responsibility for the protest chaos. If elections do not happen as scheduled, the increased violence will take a toll that the city will not recover from.


Legislative Council of Hong Kong

Carrie Lam

Hong Kong Basic Law

Executive Council of Hong Kong

Xi Jinping

Hong Kong police

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)


Column

Carrie Lam has lit Hong Kong ablaze. A failure to hold district council elections would be the final betrayal

Carrie Lam, and the pro-Beijing politicians who enabled her, should not forget their responsibility for the protest chaos If elections do not happen as scheduled, the increased violence will take a toll that the city will not recover from

Carrie Lam, and the pro-Beijing politicians who enabled her, should not forget their responsibility for the protest chaos

If elections do not happen as scheduled, the increased violence will take a toll that the city will not recover from