Advertisement

Opinion | Money-laundering crackdown is just a way to blame Chinese cash for Vancouver’s unaffordable housing

  • Documenting the origin of every dollar is impossible and while the new Land Owner Transparency Act may reveal Chinese are main buyers of luxury real estate, this is no fodder for money-laundering claims, only for jealousy

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Cash being processed in a Vancouver casino, released by the British Columbia government in a report on money laundering. Photo: Province of British Columbia

A joke about Canadians is that they hate rich people — but if they become rich, then they say they hate poor people. Such is the “culture of envy” that flourishes in a country based on political correctness.

Advertisement
The British Columbia government has embarked on a misguided investigation into local and foreign money laundering and their effects on the local economy, particularly in casinos and real estate. It is actually racist speak for: let us find a way to blame Chinese money for the greater Vancouver area’s chronically unaffordable housing.
Vancouver media rarely complains about money laundering and real estate ownership by Europeans or Americans. Instead, story after story describe the Ferrari-driving, Chinese youth who is also the titled owner of a luxury home.

The investigation fails to grasp a basic understanding of global capital flow, financial regulations, current practices of “know your client”, and anti-money-laundering policies. Most of all, the province has little jurisdiction over what are federal issues. It is mainly a public-relations exercise chasing the ghost of the Chinese money launderer.

No one advocates money laundering, because it flows from predicate offences such as tax avoidance and other criminal activities. Tax planning is not necessarily illegal tax avoidance. But asking foreigners to justify the ultimate origin of every dollar is trying to prove a negative — that they have no criminal intent — which is impossible.

Advertisement
Slot machines at Vancouver’s River Rock Casino. Photo: Bloomberg
Slot machines at Vancouver’s River Rock Casino. Photo: Bloomberg
Advertisement