Advertisement

Opinion | Debate between Fox’s Trish Regan and CGTN’s Liu Xin revealed China’s defiance on intellectual property

  • In her comments on US accusations of Chinese intellectual property infringements and the state sector, the CGTN anchor echoed the more defensive stance China has been taking on these issues

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
CGTN anchor Liu Xin (right) and Fox Business Network host Trish Regan engage in a live television discussion on the China-US trade war, on May 30. Photo: Twitter
As a Taiwan-born Chinese living in the United States, I had no problem picking sides when watching the highly anticipated “debate” between Trish Regan, anchor of Fox Business Network’s Primetime, and Liu Xin, host of CGTN’s The Point. I secretly rooted for Liu, not only out of empathy and respect for someone speaking up in a second language, but also because I knew she faced an uphill battle proving her case without sounding like a demagogue.
Advertisement

In Regan’s opening statement, she referred to Liu as a member of the Chinese Communist Party, a characterisation that Liu immediately disputed. Although they talked past each other during this exchange, that looked more like a function of delays in satellite transmission than fighting over the microphone.

But two hours after the conclusion of the programme, the top trending hashtag on Weibo, one of China’s biggest social media platforms, was, “Liu Xin was interrupted by Trish at least three times in 30 seconds”, with related posts generating 11 billion views and 15,000 comments.

Regan sought Liu’s views on China’s intellectual property (IP) violations by confronting her with a rolling on-screen roster of notable examples of IP theft by China. Liu conceded: “I do not deny that there are IP infringements, there are copyright issues, piracy or even theft of commercial secrets. That’s something that has to be dealt with.”

While Regan took this to be an admission of China’s IP infringements, it is equally important to listen to Liu’s qualification: “I think that’s a common practice probably in every part of the world and there are companies in the United States who sue each other all the time over infringement on IP rights, and you can’t say simply because these cases are happening that America is stealing or China is stealing or the Chinese people are stealing.”

Advertisement
US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer (left) sits across Chinese Vice-Premier Liu He (right) during US-China trade talks in Washington on February 21. Intellectual property infringements by Chinese companies have been a long-standing US complaint. Photo: AFP
US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer (left) sits across Chinese Vice-Premier Liu He (right) during US-China trade talks in Washington on February 21. Intellectual property infringements by Chinese companies have been a long-standing US complaint. Photo: AFP
Advertisement