Advertisement

Letters | Why the US democracy summit was neither fish nor fowl

  • Readers discuss the rich irony of America hosting a democracy summit, question the assertion that low voter turnout suggests good governance, and argue for iAM Smart to replace ID cards

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
US President Joe Biden boards Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland on December 8. Photo: AFP
The US has held a virtual democracy summit in an attempt to burnish its image and rope in allies to counter China’s peaceful rise (“US opens Summit for Democracy, with Joe Biden calling for moves to counter authoritarianism as America eyes China”, December 10). But the outcome may well go against its wishes.
Advertisement
Among the 110 participants that the Biden administration invited to its first Summit for Democracy was Taiwan. Taipei was clearly aware of how it should behave in such a delicate situation and did not dare to send its leader. Instead, it appointed Digital Minister Audrey Tang and de facto ambassador to the US Hsiao Bi-khim as its representatives.

Can such a meeting still call itself a summit – by definition a meeting of government heads? Seeing such a neither-fish-nor-fowl title, one cannot help but cite Confucius: “If names be not correct, language is not in accordance with the truth of things.”

The Taiwan problem has been America’s “trump card” in dealing with Beijing and, normally, Washington does not play this card rashly. But recently, the US has made frequent use of the Taiwan problem to create trouble for China. This suggests there are fewer cards left for Washington to provoke China and attempt to slow down its development.

01:16

Don’t ‘play with fire’: Mainland China tells US for inviting Taiwan to democracy summit

Don’t ‘play with fire’: Mainland China tells US for inviting Taiwan to democracy summit

The US hosting the summit may also be a response to the shift in global public opinion. Since the 2008 financial crisis, in Western countries, including the US, problems – such as governance efficiency, a widening wealth gap and economic stagnation – have become increasingly acute. In particular, there have been failures in the fight against Covid-19. In contrast, China’s economy is flourishing and its government has done a good job of containing Covid-19.

Advertisement
Advertisement