Advertisement

Trump’s immigration U-turn shows he’s no Hitler, but solving the problem requires more than sympathy for asylum seekers

Niall Ferguson says that neither the US nor the EU can realistically absorb all the migrants who would move there if they could, and a legal solution is required

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Craig Stephens
I am an immigrant – a legal one. Over 16 years, I've gone through a succession of work visas, acquired a green card, married an American citizen (herself an immigrant), passed the citizenship test and will very soon take the naturalisation oath, accompanied by my wife and our two American-born sons.
Advertisement
Since 2002, I and members of my family have entered the United States umpteen times. Occasionally, those crossings have been fraught. Once, before she got her green card, my British-born daughter was held up by immigration officers, who doubted that she was visiting her father.
So I can understand the moral outrage over the separation of asylum-seeking parents from their children at the US-Mexican border.
I can sympathise, too, with the parents, most of whom are from poor and violent Central American countries. My wife was once an asylum seeker from a poor and violent country. Her main motive for leaving Somalia for Holland (via Kenya and Germany) was to avoid an arranged marriage to a man she scarcely knew.
Displaced Somali girls who fled the drought in southern Somalia stand in a queue to receive food handouts at a centre in Mogadishu, in February 2017. Photo: AP
Displaced Somali girls who fled the drought in southern Somalia stand in a queue to receive food handouts at a centre in Mogadishu, in February 2017. Photo: AP
Advertisement
Advertisement