Advertisement

Trump’s UN speech and Germany’s election show borders are back

Niall Ferguson says boundaries between countries are determined more by force than logic or democracy, and the rejection today of globalism by the likes of Donald Trump will only harm small nations

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Huntsville, Alabama. The US president dialled up the rhetoric at the United Nations, saying his country would have “to totally destroy North Korea” if forced to defend itself or its allies. Photo: AP

In 1985, five European states signed the Schengen Agreement, abolishing border checks between them. In 1996, John Perry Barlow wrote his Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace, addressed to the “governments of the industrial world”. He told them: “Cyberspace does not lie within your borders.”

Advertisement
Two decades later, borders are back. In his speech last week to the United Nations General Assembly, Donald Trump was unequivocal: “If we aspire to the approval of history, then we must fulfil our sovereign duties to the people we faithfully represent. We must protect our nations, their interests and their futures.

“As president of the United States,” he said, “I will always put America first, just like you, as the leaders of your countries, will always, and should always, put your countries first.” Trump’s assertion was one of the few lines in the speech that won applause.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel casts her ballot in Berlin on Sunday. The conservative union led by Merkel defended its commanding role in the Bundestag with 32.5 per cent of the vote but fell short of expectations. Photo: Xinhua
German Chancellor Angela Merkel casts her ballot in Berlin on Sunday. The conservative union led by Merkel defended its commanding role in the Bundestag with 32.5 per cent of the vote but fell short of expectations. Photo: Xinhua
The world is not in a globalist mood. Brexit is about reasserting sovereignty, above all over immigration. Angela Merkel has been re-elected German chancellor, but her party’s share of the vote reduced, mainly because of Germany’s borders. Trump clings to his election promise to build a wall along the US-Mexican border and exclude citizens of mainly Muslim countries associated with terrorism. European elites sneer, but polls show majorities of their citizens would support a similar ban on Muslim immigration.

Yet when you reflect on borders, you see how strange the world is. Ninety-five per cent of all people live in fewer than 90 countries. Yet the United Nations has 193 members. Among its most recent recruits are East Timor (1.3 million) and Montenegro (629,000).

Advertisement
Why do the Kurds, numbering up to 45 million, not yet have a nation state with borders of their own? Why do the Catalans not? On Monday Iraqi Kurdistan voted on independence from Iraq. Next Sunday, Catalonia is due to vote on independence from Spain. Neither poll is seen as legitimate by the states from which Kurds and Catalans would secede. Yet if the Pacific island Nauru (11,359) is a sovereign state, what is the argument against independent Kurdistan or Catalonia?

Myanmar cartoonists lead the media in jeering Rohingya

Advertisement