Advertisement

Hong Kong’s young democrats need some lessons on democracy

Kerry Kennedy says the uncivil behaviour displayed by students in the row over pro-independence posters on university campuses runs counter to democratic values such as tolerance, fairness and open-mindedness

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Social media in particular creates a bubble for students. They listen only to views that are the same as theirs, they form peer groups around social media platforms, thus sealing the bubble even more, and they constantly have their views reinforced. Illustration: Craig Stephens

Many Hong Kong students benefit from 12 years of education, then those who are lucky enough get to go to publicly funded universities. The assumption for those lucky ones is that they have learned a lot in their 12 years and will continue to do so in university.

Advertisement

Yet recent events at several local institutions suggest that, for some young people, their learning has been illusory – perhaps something they can perform well at in an examination room but not something that equips them to be tolerant and caring citizens of the future.

The case of those still unknown Education University students who posted despicable comments about the tragic death of the son of the undersecretary for education stands out as reflecting a lack of tolerance, care and just plain human decency. To make matters worse, such an action was defended by the student union president as “freedom of speech”.

Together, these attitudes reflect a stunning lack of understanding about what it means to be a human being and what democratic theory teaches about freedom. This seems ironic, since the offending material was placed on a “democracy wall”. Yet democracy does not support these students’ actions or views.

Don’t blame all students for ‘isolated incidents’ involving malicious messages

Members of the students’ union at Chinese University speak to Dennis Ng, the university’s pro-vice-chancellor, on September 8. Photo: K.Y. Cheng
Members of the students’ union at Chinese University speak to Dennis Ng, the university’s pro-vice-chancellor, on September 8. Photo: K.Y. Cheng
Advertisement
Advertisement