Advertisement

Only the truth about what really happened to bookseller Lee Po will calm the jitters in Hong Kong

John Chan says total honesty from Beijing on the case would do more to win over local hearts and minds than any propaganda war it can mount against seekers of Hong Kong independence

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A poster supporting the missing booksellers is seen on the stairs leading up to Causeway Bay Books, just days after Lee Po, the proprietor of the shop, reappeared in Hong Kong. Photo: EPA

The bits of information provided by Lee Po since his return from the mainland more than three months after he mysteriously vanished have not helped to clear the suspicion and widely held belief that he did not voluntarily smuggle himself across the border.

Fog of uncertainty descends on Hong Kong in wake of bookseller ‘mess’

When his wife filed a missing person report after he went missing, Lee phoned and faxed his wife from the mainland telling her that he went “by means of his own choice”. The fact that there is no record of his passing through immigration control on leaving Hong Kong last December raised doubts about his statement.

It is hard for ordinary people to take what Lee said as the whole truth and stop asking questions
If he did so, as he has repeatedly stressed, there are two unanswered questions. They arose from Lee’s interview with Mingjing News , a Chinese-language news portal based in New York. In the interview, Lee said that last December he felt that, as a boss, he was obliged to help his three employees then being held by mainland authorities, saying that “someone asked me whether I was willing to return [to the mainland].” He also said a friend made arrangements for him but refused to reveal who accompanied him.
Advertisement

Thus, the first question is: who was that person who suggested or invited him to go to the mainland and did he go under duress?

The second question is: if it was suggested he go, or he was invited to go to sort out his employees’ plight, why would he not choose to do so through the normal border control checkpoint, like everyone else?

It is thus hard for ordinary people to take what Lee said as the whole truth and stop asking questions surrounding his mysterious disappearance and seemingly carefully staged reappearance.

It is even more difficult to ask people to put the matter to rest and stop the wild guessing that he did not go voluntarily.

Advertisement
If Lee Po did not go to the mainland voluntarily, it is a serious matter. Was he threatened, or even abducted by Chinese law enforcement personnel? Photo: Edward Wong
If Lee Po did not go to the mainland voluntarily, it is a serious matter. Was he threatened, or even abducted by Chinese law enforcement personnel? Photo: Edward Wong
Advertisement