Advertisement

Whether in public or in private, Britain was right to bring up human rights during Xi Jinping's state visit

Toh Han Shih welcomes the fact that the issues of democracy and rights were raised during Xi Jinping's state visit to Britain, given the huge investment flows coming from China

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Xi Jinping delivers a speech to the British Parliament. Photo: AFP
Xi Jinping delivers a speech to the British Parliament. Photo: AFP
Xi Jinping delivers a speech to the British Parliament. Photo: AFP
Advertisement
UK House of Commons speaker John Bercow publicly raised the issue of human rights with Xi Jinping, while the leader of the British opposition Labour party Jeremy Corbyn did the same, but in private, during the Chinese leader's state visit to Britain. It is right and proper that the two did so, despite warnings by the Chinese ambassador to the UK, Liu Xiaoming, that Xi would be offended if he was lectured on human rights.
If Corbyn were to one day become prime minister, would he welcome the huge Chinese investments into the UK, as Cameron is doing?

When introducing Xi to the House of Commons on Tuesday, Bercow pointedly said: "We have had no fewer than four prominent daughters and sons of Asia in our Parliament in the past three years, starting with Aung Sang Suu Kyi of Burma, the Nobel Peace Prize winner, democracy champion and international symbol of the innate human right of freedom … In all matters, from international law to individual liberty, we should all aspire to be seen not merely as a powerful force in the world but as a moral inspiration to it."

Although Bercow's speech did not directly mention China's record on human rights and democracy, it is obvious that he was indirectly referring to it.

Corbyn raised the issue in a private meeting with Xi at Buckingham Palace on Tuesday, and did not touch on it publicly at a state banquet later that day. This was a win-win compromise for both sides, because it spared the Chinese leader from losing face. Xi should be given credit for agreeing to hear out the opposition leader.

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn raised the issue of human rights in a private meeting with Xi Jinping at Buckingham Palace, and did not touch on it publicly at a state banquet later that day. Photo: Xinhua
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn raised the issue of human rights in a private meeting with Xi Jinping at Buckingham Palace, and did not touch on it publicly at a state banquet later that day. Photo: Xinhua
Advertisement
Advertisement