Advertisement

Off Centre | All that glitters is not a golden era for Sino-British relations as nuclear plant stalls

Power station saga continues to unravel despite Chinese state firm’s backing

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Britain’s Sellafield nuclear power plant. The UK and China are planning on building at least two more nuclear plants in the future. Photo: Reuters

Ever since the British bulldog resolved to apply a deferential tongue to the current Chinese leadership’s boots, things have gone swimmingly between the two nations. Hailed by both sides, the “golden time” now under way in Sino-British trade and investment is due in no small part to Prime Minister David Cameron’s doggedness in wooing Beijing. That, of course, and his government’s readiness to rule out any more meetings with the Dalai Lama.

Advertisement

One component in this new state of accord already appears gravely imperilled, however. In October, the state nuclear firm CGN (China General Nuclear) announced it would be taking a 33.5 per cent stake in delivering Britain’s first new nuclear power station in a generation: Hinkley Point C, in Somerset, England. At the time, the slated majority partner, EDF – a French government-owned energy company – said work on building the plant’s reactors would start within weeks.

China put down a £6 billion stake in the UK's first nuclear power plant since the 1980s during Xi Jinping’s state visit last year. Photo: AP
China put down a £6 billion stake in the UK's first nuclear power plant since the 1980s during Xi Jinping’s state visit last year. Photo: AP
Flash forward four months and things do not look good. EDF last week postponed a final decision on its investment as it reported a 68 per cent downturn in profits for 2015. The company’s share price has more than halved in the last year, while its reduced market value is less than the £18 billion (HK$200 billion) Hinkley will cost (at low estimates).

The source of EDF’s financial difficulties is low electricity wholesale market prices. The reasons for the British government’s desperation to get CGN involved are slightly more tangled.

READ MORE: China General Nuclear Power expands overseas plant construction business

To shorten a long story, a decade ago Britain struck on nuclear as its best option for keeping the lights on while it sets about the bold, and some might say foolhardy, mission of cutting carbon emissions to 60 per cent of 1990 levels by 2030. Nuclear, the panjandrums said, would be more cost-effective than investing in green energy, at least for the time being. One nuclear tech company, Areva, said it could build reactors that would produce electricity profitably at £24 per megawatt-hour. Better get cracking, then, lads.

Following the recent price collapse, £92.50 [a megawatt-hour] amounts to more than double the current market rate.

In February 2007, EDF announced its intention to have Hinkley Point C operational by Christmas 2017. Little in the way of activity ensued, however. The Fukushima disaster of 2011 came hard on the heels of the financial crash. Other investors fell by the wayside. Then, suddenly, in December 2013, the government agreed a deal to pay EDF a guaranteed £92.50 per MWh, index-linked for 35 years after commissioning. The deal safeguards the firm against fluctuations in the market price: any slack will be picked up by British households. Following the recent price collapse, £92.50 amounts to more than double the current market rate.

Advertisement