Advertisement

Jake's View | China’s got a trade problem that can’t be solved by Belt and Road

Take away the trade surpluses with the US and European Union, and China has pretty much consistently run a big trade deficit with the rest of the world

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The Belt and Road International Food Expo 2018 highlighted opportunities related to food investment during a conference held in Hong Kong in June 2017. Photos; Dickson Lee

After years of growth, China’s trade ties with its biggest partner, the European Union, seems to be foundering, with frictions growing over a range of issues from steel overcapacity to market access and the South China Sea.

SCMP, February 19

You may recall a photo we published a while back of a group of cheerleaders waving China flags as a goods train pulled out of the station in London, destined for Beijing with British export goods, the Belt and Road in action.

Advertisement

I laughed. I am sure I had company. Any good-sized container ship carries up to 100 times what such a train can carry to China and does it more efficiently and at much lower cost than the easily overcrowded track and different rail gauges will allow any train to do it on the journey.

A freight train transporting containers laden with goods from China, arriving at DB Cargo's London Eurohub rail freight depot in Barking, east London on January 18, 2017. Photo: AFP
A freight train transporting containers laden with goods from China, arriving at DB Cargo's London Eurohub rail freight depot in Barking, east London on January 18, 2017. Photo: AFP

That’s Belt and Road for you, a storm of hot air that sycophants emit as evidence of their eagerness to obey commands from Beijing, a reactive measure started only because the national authorities were annoyed that a multinational trade pact proposed by the United States would exclude China.

Well, if you exclude us, we’ll exclude you, they said. We’ll do business with Uganda and the stans instead, so there.

Advertisement

And all I can say for this is that it has wasted much less money than it has wasted breath so far and may yet be wound down before real money is lost.

But if the European Union is now to follow the recent US lead and seriously propose much tighter restrictions on imports from China, here are two charts to put the unimportance of Mauritius and Kyrgyzstan into perspective.

Advertisement