Advertisement

Life or death decisions

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP

Twenty-one-year-old Holly Shaw spends three hours a day, three days a week having dialysis in hospital. The student at Britain's Chester University was diagnosed with renal failure three years ago and was put on the waiting list for a kidney transplant.

Advertisement

Holly is one of more than 9,000 people in Britain who are waiting for organs which could save their lives. While the dialysis keeps Holly alive, 1,000 patients in Britain die every year because there were no organs available for them.

In Britain only 13 people in every million donate their organs. That is a relatively low figure among European countries but is already three times higher than that of Hong Kong. Last year only 58 patients on the 1,500-long waiting list received a kidney transplant in the city. One of them had been waiting for as long as 24 years.

Organ donation has been promoted by governments and charities for decades, yet it is difficult to get people to commit to giving their organs. It is also difficult to get grieving families to agree to give up their loved one's organs.

Last month British Prime Minister Gordon Brown suggested the nation shift to a 'presumed consent' system in which individuals are automatically considered donors after death unless they choose to opt out of the system by registration.

Advertisement

This is in sharp contrast to the current system of expressed consent - as exists in Hong Kong - in which only those who have previously signed an organ donation card or whose family agree to donate their organs can be regarded as donors.

The major problem of the expressed consent system is the low registration rate of donors. Death is a topic that people avoid. Many people who fully support organ donation do not take the initiative to sign a donation card. When death occurs, devastated families tend to preserve the bodies of their loved ones.

Advertisement